Limitations of Walled Gardens for Internet Advertising

Walled gardens play an important role in controlling users' access to valuable content. Learn how to implement them and help collect your own first party data.

Last updated:

Logo Logo

V DIGITAL SERVICES Product Insights

Scaling Walled Gardens With First-Party Data

Featured image for post: Scaling Walled Gardens With First-Party Data

On September 12, 2024

People often bounce around online, moving from social media platforms like Twitter to shopping on Amazon, eBay, or Etsy with just a few clicks. To keep users engaged, platforms like Facebook and TikTok create “walled gardens” — closed ecosystems where they collect user data and serve targeted ads, keeping people on their sites longer. While this works well for the platforms, it can be costly and restrictive for businesses trying to advertise across multiple channels.

What if advertisers had an alternative to relying solely on the limited data available within walled gardens? Instead of depending solely on the limited data provided by walled garden platforms to reach audiences, businesses could tap into their own first-party data. This approach enables them to upload and utilize their data for more precise targeting, blending the detailed targeting of walled gardens with the expansive reach of the open web.

What Is a Walled Garden? (In Relation to the Internet)?

A walled garden is a digital space, like a website or app, that controls what users can see and do. It keeps users inside by limiting their access to only what’s served within that space, whether they’re browsing, shopping, or communicating. Walled gardens are closed ecosystems that maintain strict control over who sees what content and how businesses are permitted to advertise within the environment.

Who Uses Walled Gardens in Their Platforms & Advertising?

Google is a prime example of a walled garden in digital advertising. Its platform controls the visibility of ads across its search engine, YouTube, and other Google-owned sites. Advertisers must follow Google’s specific rules and bidding systems to reach users. If you want to advertise, you have to play by their rules, and if you’re not on their platforms, you’re missing out on a huge audience.

Other examples of walled gardens are Meta, which includes Facebook and Instagram, and Amazon Advertising. These platforms amongst others control around 70% of all ad spending, a share that continues to grow. However, businesses often face challenges due to the strict targeting policies imposed by these walled gardens, which can limit their ability to fully understand customer preferences and optimize their marketing strategies.

The Current Challenge of Marketing in a Walled Garden

Walled Gardens take power from businesses and their marketing campaigns by making them rely solely upon the user data they’ve collected and confined to a specific platform. For example, Meta only has access to what users do on Facebook or Instagram, and Google only knows about their activities on Google services. This is because the data you have access to within walled gardens isn’t raw data but instead formatted within the platform’s tools and metrics. As a result, you stay wholly reliant upon third parties who know more about your prospects and customers than you.

Unlock First-Party Data

Your solution to the common struggles that businesses navigate when advertising within walled gardens, is first-party data. First-party data is audience insight that you fully own, control, and can leverage across any marketing platform including walled gardens.

What Is It?

In marketing, there are four types of customer data you can collect:

  • Zero-Party Data: Information proactively shared by consumers
  • First-Party Data: Data collected directly from web users or clients
  • Second-Party Data: Data collected and sold between two parties as part of partnerships
  • Third-Party Data: Aggregated or sold data parties that aren’t end-users or data collection platforms

First-party data is the most reliable as it is the personal information that they directly share with you in the process is first-party data. The more first-party data that you independently collect, the more you’ll invariably know about the people you serve or intend to serve.

How Can My Business Collect First-Party Data?

There are multiple ways to collect first-party data:

  • Use your website to implement an analytics platform
  • Have new clients create accounts, register, or opt into email marketing campaigns
  • Integrate your social media profiles
  • Create and send feedback forms and surveys
  • Purchase and use a quality CRM and platform
  • Use session recordings and heatmaps to track user behaviors

However, you’ll have to use all of these things and more to get results that outperform the data you’ve been relying on behind walled gardens. With V Audience Labs’ innovative first-party data solution, Prospect Hub, you can instantly identify up to 30% of the anonymous users on your website. Prospect Hub leverages a robust network and a cutting-edge identity resolution graph to create rich, detailed customer profiles. Simultaneously, Prospect Hub ensures consent with an integrated Consent Management Platform that ensures your first-party data is pulled following up-to-date privacy laws.

How Prospect Hub, Our First-Party Data Solution, Helps Your Business Scale Walled Gardens

With Prospect Hub, collecting and owning your audience data is simplified. Our marketing technology helps you take back control over your own data, so you can manage and activate marketing campaigns both within and outside of walled gardens like Google or Facebook. Using Prospect Hub, you can leverage a world-class data cooperative to resolve customer information, allowing you to run targeted ads across various channels and fully integrate your first-party data for optimized advertising strategies.

In Practice: First-Party Data Activations

Use Prospect Hub to identify new site visitors and resolve both B2B and B2C data for detailed firmographic, demographic, or contact information. Simply upload the relevant pieces of first-party data collected with Prospect Hub to a walled garden, tell it to target individuals that match your specified audience data points, and your ads will be served to matching prospects. V Digital Services’ client, 1-800-Plumber + Air, experienced the impact of successfully leveraging first-party data with ad clicks increasing by close to 26%.

Discover the Power of First-Party Data with Prospect Hub

Learn how to overcome the limitations of walled gardens using our first-party data solution, Prospect Hub, for targeted advertising. V Digital Services is here to guide you through harnessing the full power of your own data for unparalleled marketing success. Contact us to learn how we can help you make the most of your first-party data in today’s competitive environment.

Post navigation

arrow left PREVIOUS

NEXT arrow right

Get the latest news and industry trends

MORE LIKE THIS

Cheap Clicks, Lower Conversions: How to Navigate the New Paid Media Landscape

August 19, 2026

Is Your TV Ad Budget Secretly Wasted? Why VDS Changes the OTT/CTV Game

August 5, 2026

The Death of the “Blanket” Broadcast: Hyper-Localism in Political Marketing

August 3, 2026

First-Party Data in Action: How Prospect Hub Transforms Your Customer Insights into Growth

May 29, 2026

How V Digital Services Is Using Birdeye to Support Modern Local SEO

May 29, 2026

The CEO’s Guide to Google Performance Max (PMax) in 2026

May 6, 2026

Your 2026 Website Survival Guide: Balancing Peak Performance with ADA Compliance

May 5, 2026

Data, Privacy, and the New Reality of Marketing ROI

March 24, 2026

What a High-Accountability Digital Marketing Program Looks Like

March 10, 2026

From The Experts: How User Behavior is Shaping Organic SEO in 2026

February 12, 2026

VDS Logo premierbadge MBP Badge Light backgrounds@2x CLIENT LOGIN TWP_Colored Call (888) 441-0784

Sign Up to Get the latest news and industry trends!

2026 V Digital Services | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | SITEMAP | Privacy | Terms Of Use | Cookies | Accessibility | Your Privacy Rights

Use of this website constitutes acceptance of our policies linked above. V Digital Services may earn a portion of sales from products & services purchased through links on our site from our affiliate partners. ©2026 V Digital Services, LLC. All rights reserved.Do Not Sell or Share My Information